Drugstore Dupe Alert: Better than the real thing?

Press Sample
Purchased by Me 



Quick question for you:




Which shade do you prefer? They look pretty similar, right? But if you were forced to choose one, which would you pick?


Here's another shot of the exact same swatches, in slightly different lighting:






Personally, I'd go with the one on the right. It's a bit richer to me, and more wearable for my particular skintone. If YOU would